Differentiate between Braced and Unbraced Columns
Ravin Desai is Co-Founder of gharpedia.com and Director of SDCPL. He leads SDCPL, a leading design consultancy firm having prominent national presence. He has a Master’s degree in Civil Engineering (MS-USA) and has diverse experience of 12 years in multiple disciplines. He is the core member of Editorial team at GharPedia. He is also co-founder of 1mnt.in, the first-in-Industry software for contractors’ billing.
What is Bracing?
Bracings are structural components or assemblies that are intended to prevent buckling or reduce the effective unsupported length of columns, truss chords, towers and other members or structures loaded in compression. In particular cases, the same bracing is also used to withstand externally applied loads.
An adequate brace system requires both strength (to provide the necessary stabilizing forces) and stiffness(to limit the deformation of the braced components or structures and to cause them to behave in an intentional manner).In so many situations, the stiffness and strength requirements are correspondent to each other i.e. Less stiffness allows for greater deformations, which in turn results in more force on the bracing.
Braced frames are a very ordinary form of construction, being simple to analyses and economical to construct. Economy results from, nominally pinned connections between beams and columns. Bracing, which resists lateral loads and provides stability, generally comes from diagonal steel members or, from a concrete ‘core’. In braced construction, beams and columns are designed under vertical load only, assuming the bracing system to take all lateral loads.
Use of Bracing
A braced frame is a structural system generally used in structures subject to lateral loads due to wind and earthquake. The members in a braced frame are generally made of structural steel, which can work adequately both in compression and tension.
Design of Bracing
Bracing and its proper design (including its strength and stiffness) in real structures are topics of major concern to structural designers and engineers since both bracing and its design are important to their own stability performance under working loading conditions, as well as the overall integrity of the structure under extreme loadings such as those caused by severe earthquakes and strong winds or lateral loads. It is a general practice to design framed structures with lateral bracings to protect them against excessive lateral sways and deflections, to avoid buckling and premature collapses. This is done to get safe and economical designs.
Advantages of Braced Building
- Due to bracing of the buildings, lateral storey displacement, storey drift as well as axial force and bending moment in columns can be reduced to a noticeable level.
- Reduction in lateral displacement is an uppermost advantage. Concentric ‘X’ bracing is more effective than Eccentric ‘V’ bracing.
- Braced frames resist the seismic forces and wind, much more than non-braced buildings.
- Steel bracing is economical, easy to erect, consumes less space and has flexibility to design for achieving the required strength and stiffness.
Types of Bracing
01. Single Diagonals
02. Cross Bracing
04. V Bracing
05. Eccentric Bracing
A structural system consists of different members such as footing, braced and unbraced column, beam, slab etc.
Braced and unbraced columns are basically vertical members which go throughout the height of the structural system i.e. from foundation to terrace.
The column can be categorized on different basis depending on its cross-section, length, behaviour, cross bracing, longitudinal reinforcement etc.
- Unbraced columns are designed to resist lateral loads, or rather they need to be designed for lateral loads.
- In braced frames lateral loads like wind, earthquake, etc are resisted by some special arrangement like shear wall, bracings or special supports. Hence the column sizes can be optimized.
- In unbraced frames lateral loads like wind, earthquake, etc are resisted by columns or which makes column heavy and large size.
- Sidesway or joint translation occurs in such columns to a large extent.
- Unbraced columns are subjected to sway.
- Most of the RCC structures are design by this method.
- Unbraced columns are less resistant to Earthquake than braced column.
- It is easy to provide opening between two unbraced columns.
- Used in RCC framed structures where low story buildings are to be constructed.
- Structural System having bracing are mostly used in important/special structures, high-rise building, communication towers etc. rather it is must here.
- Structural System without bracing are mostly used in normal low-rise structures.
- A braced column is connected (generally above midway) with a beam/tie back to a structure or to a ground footing or even the base of another column.
- An unbraced column is a free-standing column.
- A braced column is considered as short if both the slenderness ratio lex/h and ley/b are less than 15. If either ratio is greater than 15, the column is considered as long (slender).
- An unbraced column is considered as short if both the slenderness ratio lex/h and ley/b are less than 10. If either ratio is greater than 10, the column is considered as long (slender).
- The overall strength and stiffness of the building are more as compared to unbraced column.
- The overall strength and stiffness of the building are less as compared to braced column.
Must Read: Difference Between Beam & Column
The resisting capacity of braced frame against sidesway is always remarkably larger than that of the unbraced frame. A braced building is the one which is reinforced by steel members which increase the compressive as well as tensile strength of the building.