Property Insurance and Renter’s Insurance: Which One to Choose?

The type of Property Insurance you need depends on whether you own or rent your home. Home and renter insurance provide essential coverage but for different aspects of your home. Homeowners should consider getting Property Insurance, which protects the house’s structure and belongings against damages.

Alternatively, the renter’s insurance only covers the belongings and liability, as the landlord is responsible for the building’s structure. Knowing the difference between the two policies can help you make an informed choice to avoid financial loss. Let’s see how each one works and which one suits you better.

What is Property Insurance?

Property Insurance is a policy designed for homeowners to provide financial coverage for their home and personal property. It is a policy to cover diverse risks so that the homeowners can be reimbursed for unexpected damage. A typical Property Insurance policy will include:

  • Dwelling Coverage: Covers the physical house, walls, roof, and attached features from perils such as fire, storm, and vandals.
  • Personal Property Coverage: Insures personal items within the house, including furniture, electronics, and apparel, against covered causes of loss.
  • Liability Coverage: Offers money coverage if a person is hurt on the property or if the homeowner is responsible for damage to someone else’s property.
  • Additional Living Expenses (ALE): Covers a temporary dwelling and associated expenses if the house is rendered uninhabitable due to a covered occurrence.
  • Other Structures Coverage: Insures structures on the property that are not included in the main dwelling, like garages, sheds, and fences.

Property Insurance is generally mandated by lenders who issue mortgages to safeguard their investment in the property. Even without a mortgage, homeowners are strongly advised to obtain financial protection against unforeseen losses.

What is Renter’s Insurance?

Renter’s insurance is for individuals leasing a building who do not own the building but want financial protection against their own personal property and liability hazards. It does not insure the building, which is insured differently through Property Insurance since the landlord covers it. A typical renter’s policy has:

  • Personal Property Coverage: This policy insures personal items in the rented building, such as clothes, furniture, and appliances, against loss or damage caused by fire, theft, or water.
  • Liability Coverage: This policy ensures the cost of lawyer fees if the renter becomes liable for damage to other people or loss of property by accident in the rented house.
  • Additional Living Expenses (ALE): Pays for additional living expenses if the rental property becomes uninhabitable because of a covered event.
  • Loss of Use Coverage: Pays for temporary living expenses if your rental becomes uninhabitable for a covered reason.

Renters’ insurance is not always legally required but typically is included as a lease stipulation by landlords. Even when not legally required, it is a good bet that renters should take on to protect their belongings and minimise exposure to potential liability.

Key Differences Between Property Insurance & Renter’s Insurance

Both types of insurance differ in terms of coverage, premium, and several other factors. The following table shows the differentiation between the two insurances:

FeatureProperty InsuranceRenter’s Insurance
Structural CoverageYes, covers the physical structure of the home.No, the landlord is responsible for the building.
Personal Property CoverageYes, covers personal belongings within the home.Yes, covers personal belongings within rented property.
Liability CoverageYes, covers legal liability for injury or destruction.Yes, covers liability in rented property.
Other Structures CoverageYes, ensures detached garages, fences, and sheds.No, not offered.  
ObligationMust be required by mortgage lenders.Usually recommended, sometimes required of landlords.
Land CoverageYesNo
Who holds the building in ownership?HomeownerLandlord
Protection from Natural DisasterMay have to purchase riders.Restricted generally does not pay for earthquakes or floods.
CostMore due to structure and property coverage.Less since it only covers personal property.

Property Insurance Vs Renters Insurance: Which One Should You Opt for?

Choosing between home and renters insurance depends on whether you own or rent your home. Both policies offer protection but cover different aspects of your living situation.

Property Insurance protects homeowners against property damage and personal liability. It covers the structure of the house, personal belongings, and liability for injuries occurring on the property. Home coverage is necessary for anyone who owns a home, providing financial security in instances of extensive loss or unexpected incidents.

Renters insurance protects tenants from personal property loss and liability. Unlike Property Insurance, it does not cover the building structure since that’s the landlord’s responsibility.

  • Choose Property Insurance if you own the property and want to protect the structure and belongings.
  • Choose renters insurance if you rent and must protect your personal items and liability.

Is Renters Insurance a Type of Property Insurance?

Yes, the renter’s insurance is property insurance, but it specifically covers the tenant, not the building. Unlike Property Insurance, which protects the structure of your house and its contents, renter’s insurance covers only your possessions and not the house itself. It protects your things against theft, fire, vandalism and other events.

This type of insurance offers protection against loss or damage to personal belongings in your rented house. Since the landlord is responsible for the building’s structure, the renter’s insurance protects tenants from injuries.

Deciding between home and renter’s insurance is essential in shielding yourself from financial loss. Whether you rent or own, reviewing your policy from time to time is critical to ensuring you have proper coverage.

The ideal insurance policy not only guards you against disaster but also brings you peace of mind, knowing you’re ready for whatever happens.

Also Read: Learning About Property Insurance Premiums and Savings: What You Need to Know

Do you have query?

Let our experts solve it for you while you rest