Difference between Column & Shear Wall
Mahadev Desai is the Founder and CEO of gharpedia.com and SDCPL a leading design consultancy firm having strong national presence. He has a degree in Civil Engineering (BE) and Law (LLB) and has rich experience of 45 years. Besides being the Editor in Chief, he also mentors team at GharPedia. He is associated with many professional bodies. He is also co-founder of 1mnt.in the first in Industry software for contractors’ billing. He is a voracious reader, edited 4 books, and pioneer of book reading movement in Gujarat, India.
Both concrete column and shear wall are part of structural system but every vertical element cannot be a concrete column or a shear wall. The nomenclatures depend upon the structural behavior of the member in that particular case.
- Ratio of breadth/width < 0.4
- Ratio of breadth/width > 0.4
- Concrete columns minimum width should be 200 mm as per Indian Standard. However many codes prefer it be of 300 mm for seismic resistant.
- Shear wall minimum width should be 150 mm as per Indian Standard.
- Concrete columns are less resistant to Earthquake as compared to Shear wall.
- Normally concrete columns are provided at ends of room as per structural plan.
- Shear walls run along the full length of walls.
- Concrete columns cross section can be square, rectangle, circular, I shape, L shape.
- Shear wall cross section is like vertically oriented wide beam.
- Lateral load is resisted by flexural deformation.
- Lateral load is resisted by shear deformation.
- Minimum steel in RCC Shear as per different codes:
(a) Indian Standard – 0.25%.
(b) American Standard – 0.25%
(c) British Standard – 0.4 %
- Clear surface is not possible as column offset are seen at corners.
- Clear surface without any offset is possible.
- Normally consumption of concrete is less when compared to Shear wall system.
- Normally consumption of concrete is more when compared to beam column system.
- Normally more consumption of bricks/blocks.
- Normally less consumption of bricks/blocks.
- From aesthetic point of view column is not as good as shear wall.
- From aesthetic point of view shear wall is better than column.
- Shear wall system is more efficient for high rise structure.
- Finished corners are not possible.
- Finished corners are possible.
- Provision of openings for door/window in column system is easy.
- Provision of openings in shear wall system is tedious and needs special design skills.
- Less carpet area is available as compared to shear wall.
- More carpet area is available as compared to column beam system.
- Needs skills for the placement of concrete column.
- Needs advanced skills for its placement because if not kept at proper location it may lead to adverse effect.